Saturday, May 15, 2010

The Courage to Speech

Virginia Moefu

15 May 2010

FD4

The Courage to Speak


On the 23rd of August 1963, crowds of people gathered at the steps of the Lincoln memorial to listen about issues that were known to be unsaid. During this time period African American men and women were segregated from the whites and known to be treated horribly. It was a time where African Americans were executed for speaking in public about ending segregation. Martin Luther King was a man who believed in equality for everyone. King overcame his fears and exercised his right to the First Amendment to practice the freedom of speech. The famous words of, “I have a dream that my four children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character” were his way of expressing his own view point’s so he could be heard. In the end, his speech opened many eyes but a lot of people rallied and persecuted him. Our country has been privileged with many opportunities to express our selves through the Constitution but why are asked to censor our thoughts when it is inappropriate or unpatriotic? [Thesis] We as Americans are entitled to express our opinions through the First Amendment and should not be judged or discriminated for exercising our right to be heard. [Thesis]


In the first amendment: Overview, it clearly states, “Freedom of expression consists of the rights to freedom of speech, press, assembly and to petition the government for a redress of grievances, and the implied rights of association and belief” therefore allows everyone and anyone in the United States to say whatever they please. There is no fine print on the bottom of the Constitution that notes, “Freedom of Speech” only if it does not hurt anyone’s feelings, it was written with no limitations of what we can or cannot say. Ward Churchill who is of Indian ancestry is an American that was given the right like you and I to express his opinion without anyone harassing him. Churchill is simply exercising his right to freedom of speech and is not asking for anyone’s approval but just so that his voice is heard. Although people will argue that Churchill and King should never be put on the same level because of the many accomplishments King has done, Churchill should be recognized for someone who was brave enough to speak his mind. King knew his speech would offend others but he was not concerned with anyone else’s feelings. Churchill also knew his words would offend others but knew he had to express how he felt. The courage it took for Churchill to say things that he knew that most people would never have the nerve to do, are commendable.

A classmate Natalie Choe states, “However bigoted, erroneous, or controversial an opinion may be, we are given the freedom to think, feel, and say whatever we want, so to reprimand or limit someone from doing so would be communistic and constitutionally wrong” is one of the main reasons why Churchill is entitled to his own opinions. He is merely expressing his own views in public and not opposing on others to feel the same way as him. His only intensions were to express to others how he felt and not trying force others to share his views. He was simply trying to set an example for his students to be courageous to speak out on issues. Churchill traveled around the United States to appear as a guest speaker but was denied by some of the universities because of his controversial views. America is known as the “land of opportunity” in which most people risk their lives to come here, so why is one man denied the right to exercise his right to free speech? If we ridicule and condemn a person for expressing their viewpoints then how different are we from other communist countries.

In many countries people are at war to fight for the right to be heard. Millions of people have risked their lives just to express their thoughts and feelings. In the United States of America, the Constitution allows us to do such a thing that most people around the world are dying for. People around the world are risking their lives to come to America to live the American dream because they cannot find it in their own homelands. My parents are among the thousands, maybe millions which moved here for that same reason. My parents wanted a better life for their children so they could be given countless opportunities. The idea of being able to say what they please and not being punished for it was a sense of relief for them because it was not what they were use to in their homelands of Samoa.

I was sixteen years old when I first visited the island of Samoa and fell in love with the place where my parents called home. The beauty of the island was mesmerizing and captured every essence of paradise, or so I thought. My uncle, who was a judge at the time, invited me to his court room to witness how fortunate I was to live in America. I remember walking into the court room where I found a room full people agitated by one man who happened to be in hand cuffs. In Samoa the respect for the elders as well as high officials are known to be one of the most important laws enforced in the islands. He was brought to the court room because he spoke about his feelings about the newly elected prime minister and how things could be different if he were not elected. The people in the court room were outraged about the disrespect that was said by this man towards the prime minister. Everyone wanted this man to go to prison for speaking ill of the minister. As I sat there in disbelief that a man was going to jail just because he spoke of how he felt made me realize how lucky I was to live in America.

We are privileged to be given certain rights to allow us to express ourselves. The Constitution has given us the ability to do so by allowing us to choose our own religion, bare arms, as well as saying whatever we want to say without any repercussion. We are fortunate to have these rights that people all around the world are fighting for. We must go out and express ourselves and not be afraid to do so. We are given the opportunity to express ourselves through speech and the chance to express it so others can hear. But why are we told to keep them to ourselves because it is unpatriotic. Classmate Kimberly Malott adds, “As American citizens, we have gained so much from the people before us and at times takes it for granted because it doesn't seem pleasant” therefore proves we must not censor our right to free speech to spare someone’s feelings. We as Americans have the right given to us to speak as we please without being punished for doing so.

We are all taught the importance of our Constitution and how difficult it was to form such a document but we must not let it go to waste. The first amendment has given us the ability to speak on issues that are considered to be out of the norm but we must express them. We as adults need to inform and implement this amendment so that we can show the future generation importance of freedom of speech. According to Linda Campbell, who wrote an article expressing the relationship between high school students and the first amendment, stated, “the First Amendment are important because each generation of citizens helps define what freedom means in our society” proves that our Constitution is what allows us to be free of expressing our thoughts.

Martin Luther King and Ward Churchill both made comments about things that were known to be unpatriotic or unpleasant at the time, but they did it anyway. They overcame their own insecurities and expressed themselves. They were able to speak about issues that no one dared to speak about and should never be criticized for. Our laws in America gave them the right to express themselves through speech and should have never been discriminated against. The strength and courage it took for these men to stand up for what they believe are commendable. Although people will disagree, they are entitled to articulate their opinions and should not be mistreated. We must learn from these men and exercise our right to express our thoughts.

Works Cited

Campbell, Linda. "Star-Telegram.com." 3 February 2005. So What Does It Do for Me? 29 April 2010 [http://www.dfw.com/mld/dfw/news/columnists/linda_campbell/10805866.htm?1c].
Choe, Natalie. "Laulima Discussion: Online Postings." 23 April 2010. Defend Ward Churchill. 29 April 2010 [https://laulima.hawaii.ed/portal/site/KAP.33517.201030/page/c2a89a6c-a93e-47dd-b419-87efbb50f].
King, Martin Luther. "American Rhetoric: 100 Speeches." I Have a Dream. 29 April 2010 [http://www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/mlkihaveadream.htm].
Malott, Kimberly. "Laumlima Discussion: Online Posting." 21 April 2010. Defend Ward Churchill. 29 April 2010 [https://laulima.hawaii.edu/portal/site/KAP.33517.201030/page/c2a89a6c-a93e-47dd-b419-873ef93bb50f].
"N.D. Legal Information Institute." 5 June 2003. First Amendment: An Overview. 29 April 2010 [http://www.law.cornell.edu/topics/first_amendment.html].

Log of Completed Activities
_X__Apr. 6t- Intro to Paper #4. Read the Guidelines for Paper #4. (Confirmation reply required.)
_X__Apr. 12M- Complete readings for paper #4. (Confirmation reply required.)
_X__Apr. 16F- Laulima Discussion: Attack Ward Churchill
_X__Apr. 21W- Laulima Discussion: Defend Ward Churchill
_L__Apr. 26M- RD4 due. [50 pts] Review the guidelines. (Confirmation reply required.)
_X__Apr. 30F- RD4 reviews due [50 pts] Review the guidelines. (Confirmation reply required.)
_L__May 5W-14F- FD4 due [150 pts] Review the guidelines. (Confirmation reply required.)